It’s “Guest Blog Wednesday” featuring: Joe McNally
I’m officially nervous. Guest blog for Scott Kelby? Hmmmm. Okay, why be nervous? I’ll just go ahead and pretend I’m writing for my blog. No problem, just type away. But here’s the deal. Scott’s blog is Broadway, man; lights, limos, red carpet, strobes flashing, throngs of swells mingling by the thousands!
My blog is community theater in Piscataway. (Apologies to theater goers in Piscataway… I probably couldn’t open there, either.)
Scott’s is also a very forward looking blog. Thoughts, notions, products, gear, philosophy, approach… so much of it is about what is happening now, or about to happen, in our industry. It’s pretty cool, and it’s a must read way station for all those trying to stay afloat in the fast moving digital rapids. Scott, in short, is on top of it all.
So this is quite an honor, to be sure. It got me to thinking, here in my cave, Mac firmly gripped in my paws, looking for the “on” button, about what got me here. The simple answer is that I’ve been a photographer for 30 years. Lots of jobs, peaks, valleys, nicks, cuts and bruises, bad pictures, some good ones, crazy jobs, lousy hotels, bumpy flights, missed connections, and, like a battered suitcase, I tumbled off the baggage belt, here.
A career in photography is a journey without a destination. No idea where the road goes. But I have a notion about where it started, and from the panoramic future gazing promontory known as Photoshop Insider, I thought I’d look, like, backwards. (Threw the “like” in there. I’ve got a teenage daughter.)
Back to the work that has gone before. Not that I’m disinterested in current work. There’s a ton of great work being done, from the battlefield shooters of Iraq to the Hollywood gang filling the glossy pages of Vanity Fair. But for now, I’m talking about work that…
…has already been done. In some cases, a long time ago. Touchstones, in a word.
I have always revered those photographers who blazed the trail. With none of the tools that are available now, they created an archive that is the shoulders upon which we all stand. Looking at their work is what made me take up a camera. So when things are nuts, and my mind is splintered, and the job seems to be going horribly wrong, and I can’t buy a decent frame, and the camera feels like a dead weight around my neck instead of a means of expression, I go back to this work. It clears my head. It perks me up. It reminds me of what’s possible. It is shelter from the storm.
I thought my list of photogs, and some of their books (photo above by Anne Cahill) might be worth sharing. In no particular order:
- Cyclops, by Albert Watson (link)
Perhaps the best collection of B&W portraits, ever. Incredible. - Tough one to get… Conversations with the Dead, by Magnum shooter Danny Lyon (link) A look at life on the Texas chain gangs. The starkness of his B&W approach is almost as brutal as the life he observes.
- The work of Jay Maisel. Look at the work, and, just as importantly, listen to what he says. (link)
- Robert Capa’s body of work. Shooter, bon vivant, founder of Magnum.
He related the story of D-Day, pinned behind a steel barrier by vicious machine gun fire with a lieutenant he had played poker with the night before. Heads down, neither of them could look much beyond the barrier. Capa asked him what he saw. He replied, “I see my ma on the porch, waving my insurance policy.” Of the 106 pictures he shot that day, all but 8 were ruined in the darkroom by a lab tech who dried the negatives too vigorously. Capa also said, “If your pictures aren’t good enough, you aren’t close enough.” - No one followed this tenet of good picture making better than Larry Burrows. His Vietnam work is intense and compassionate. His photo story, “The Flight of Yankee Papa 13” is an instructional in telling a story with pictures.
- W. Eugene Smith. Life staffer
Difficult, tempestuous, brilliant. He shot, “Nurse Midwife, Maude Callen,” “Country Doctor,” and “Spanish Village.” How did one shooter make 3 of the greatest photo essays of all time? - However, in a book called, Great Photographic Essays from LIFE (tough to find), is perhaps the best photo essay ever done (link). “Working Girl: The Private Life of Gwyned Filling,” shot by the amazing and mostly forgotten Leonard McCombe.
- The Eye of the Beholder… A compendium of the work of Jim Stanfield, the legendary iron horse of the National Geographic (link). Jim is Superman, as far as I’m concerned. A body of work from one of the quintessential assignment photographers of our time.
- If I ever want to simply look at a set of pictures that exist for no other reason than they are beautiful, I go back to The Creation, by Ernst Haas. (link)
- The book, Steam, Steel and Stars, is the work of O. Winston Link, who has been described as an “authentic American genius, and a nut.” (link)
- Hot Light, Half Made Worlds: Photographs from the Tropics, by Alex Webb (link)
Few photographers have straddled the worlds of art and photojournalism as effectively. In this book, the color, the heat and the light become the narrative. - Stay This Moment, by Sam Abell (link)
Serene and powerful, all at once. - The work of William Albert Allard
In the 80’s he shot back to back essays for the Geographic, one called “Faulkner’s Mississippi,” and the other on Peru. No photog I know has ever burned that brightly for that length of time. An overview of his work is in a book called “The Photographic Essay,” (link) one of the American Photographer Masters Series, edited by Horenstein. Failing that, he has a wonderful, available book, called “Portraits of America.” (link) - Carl Mydans, Photojournalist
Carl’s pictures are not screamers. But by the end of this book, you know you have been in the hands of a remarkable storyteller. (link) - Gordon Parks
It was one of the honors of my career to have assisted Gordon for a day. LIFE was re-creating the famous Art Kane jazz photo, A Great Day in Harlem, and Gordon was the shooter. I rounded up my crew, and we gripped for him. Seeing his eye in the lens was not to be forgotten. A font of creativity as a shooter, film maker, author, poet and artist, he never stopped working. He has too many books to his credit to name here. - Pictures Under Discussion, by John Loengard (link)
The book is just like John both as a photographer and editor; pointed, intelligent, articulate. - Cornell Capa, Robert’s brother, just passed away. He edited a two volume set years ago called “The Concerned Photographer.” (link) It is a wonderful compilation of the work of legendary documentary photographers, such as Werner Bischof, David Seymour, known simply as, “Chim,” Marc Riboud, Bruce Davidson and Donald McCullen. I love McCullen, not just for his work but for what he said. “I only use a camera like I use a toothbrush. It does the job.” Next time you’re swamped with megapixels, and your brain is firing at too many frames per second, and you are trying to remember where a function was in the menu of 200 plus options of the fancy digital machine you just bought, that’s potentially a calming thought.
As we race towards the fantastic future, where we will have even more and better tools than we can imagine, it is still important to look back. Pictures last. They have power. They stay, and the important ones, just like big trees, grow roots into our soul.
- One last book: The Picture History of World War II.
A long forgotten book my dad got years ago. I still have it. I remember poring over this book when I was very young. I couldn’t believe such things had happened, and the pictures were the proof. I flipped through it, time and again, so much so, that when I looked at it just now I remembered most of the frames, even some of the layouts.
The pictures left their impression on me, even as I turned the pages at the age of 7 or so. I didn’t know it, but I was already becoming a photographer.













Love your work. I have been contemplating your most recent book too. Waiting for a big coupon from Barnes & Nobles.
One thought about your post: wish there were some female photographers in your list.
You might want to mention Robert Capa’s memoire book on World War II. Its title is ‘Slightly Out Of Focus’. Besides the fact that it is very interesting for any photographer, it is also a surprisingly bright and amusing read. This proves that he was also a great writer (originally he wanted to became a writer, he only started photographing because of a certain woman, but that’s another story)
Great guest article, thanks for it!
Thanks, Joe. I would add The Moment It Clicks to this list, for sure. I really hope one day you will share your autobiography with us. Your work is a true inspiration.
Joe,
Thanks for adding to my summer reading list!!! Great blog post
Definately, The Moment It Clicks belongs on the list, even if Joe is too modest to include it.
I’ve read my first copy so many times half the pages are dog-eared and the other half have stains of one sort or another on it.
My second copy is full of yellow highlighter marks on all the things Joe knows by heart that I need to highlight to remember.
And my third copy is …. well, right now, being read by another photographer who doesn’t seem to want to give it back!
Joe you rock man! Your book is amazing and I love your no bullshit attitude.
I hope to one day to attend one of your courses.
Keep rockin and rollin, lovin life and spreadin the knowledge.
Crash
http://www.crashtaylor.com
Thanks Joe for this excellent laundry list of photography books. I’ll be heading to the library this weekend to see what I can score.
Great quote by the way… “I can’t buy a decent frame, and the camera feels like a dead weight around my neck instead of a means of expression, …” I feel your pain!!!
Joe,
A great blog post to be sure and even more great information to add to my head.
Thanks!!
Love your work. I’m a graphic designer but I took up photography after one of your classes at Photoshop World.
I recently had the distinct pleasure of meeting Joe McNally at a DLWS workshop in the Redwoods, and he left a lasting impression. He’s the “real thing”, a “class act” and an incredibly gifted instructor. I am amazed at how much Joe was willing to share about his work and about his life. In this world of hurry up, get it done, cut corners and “OK” is good enough, I found his approach to creativity, working the shot, and making a memorable photograph to be refreshing and inspiring. My deepest thanks Joe, it was a pleasure to mingle with you for a few days.
Hi Joe,
I too love your work. Your book is very inspiring to me. If only I could have the ability to capture some of the images you have.
Thanks for your excellent blog post.
Mike
Interesting comments and a good reading list, Joe: you did Scott proud!
Balliolman
Hi Joe,
Love your work and blog. Just wondering why you pick on Piscataway? We do go to the theater
Thanks for the summer reading list!
Kelly
Is that Piscataway, NJ? I grew up there!
Take care,
-Frank
Joe,
Just think of this as opening night.
Bill
Great post, coming from Joe, this is definetly the best photo journalism/documentary reading list I´ve ever seen.
-Ben
thanks for your post here. a lot to chew on. i also wanted to let you know that i watched the video of the talk you did at amazon (those lucky ducks!). we don’t have a nap chamber here, but if you are ever in boulder let me know.
dana
(in boulder)
Hi Joe! Love your book, love your blog!
Thanks Joe. It was an honor to meet you at PSW in Orlando and have you autograph your book.
It’s funny that you mentioned the Picture History of WW II - I too got a copy at a very early age and I believe it’s still around - and I’m older than you! Great photos do make an impression.
Joe,
The Life Picture History of World War II was a book I, too, spent hours with as a child. When my folks packed up their home a year back I was hoping to add it to my collection, but it had disappeared. Bought a used copy recently and rediscovered the feelings I had as a child about it.
Thanks for all the great suggestions.
Thanks for a wonderfully inspiring Guest Blog.
Thanks for the great posts — the stories behind the pictures are very interesting — it is great to hear them. As others have said — Picture History of World War II — I remember as a child setting in my closet looking at that book. I guess my closet seemed like a safe place –war is scary, I can still remember some of those pictures, vividly. (I thinks that says I am older than dirt also). Thanks again for sharing all the photography stuff, the Google Talk was priceless. I really appreciate your kindness. kathyt
Joe, I checked out your book I really like it.
Mike
If any one gets a chance please check out my site, thanks.
click on my name..
Wow! You can write too!
Aloha Joe, this is Randy the Hula Photographer from Maui. Seems like things have really been buzzing for you lately! I brag to my friends that we shot together one afternoon before I had ever heard your name….
Yesterday I had a young girl walk into my gallery on Maui and she just happened to have your book under her arm — it was a soft-cover and it was pretty torn and tattered. She had been carrying it all over Hawaii and reading it on her honeymoon here. I said,”Oh, Joe , Scott and Annie Cahill and I shot together on the beach a couple of months back.” The girl stepped back and started bowing to me in respect for you guys!
Love your point of view, Joe.
Aloha,
Randy
Joe (or should I say Mr. McNally, unless of course you don’t like sir, then you’re just “Joe”),
Wonderfully inspiring work; loved “The Moment It Clicks” The pages inspired me to look deeper into why I make images and how light can drastically change them. Ironic how you mention picking up books after years of not thumbing through their pages; years from now, I can imagine those of us who own your book will do that very thing with it. Growing up, my parents subscribed to National Geographic, so undoubtedly In have seen some of your images before I had ever heard of you. I have saved every issue and go to them often for that very thing you describe…. inspiration, motivation, and solidity. It reminds me why I love making images, why I take that hunk of metal everywhere, and that each moment I capture will never happen again. Thanks for giving back!
Kind Regards,
Doug
I was delighted to realize that I, too, had admired some of the same photographers you mention, and that I could visualize their photos still as you mentioned them. All I have to do now is read the other books you mentioned that I didn’t read, and then take all your clients away from you. Simple.
I love your line “A career in photography is a journey without a destination.” This is beautiful and very accurate. The problem is we so often want to “end up” somewhere and miss out of the journey. Thanks for The Moment It Clicks. Just got it for my 50th birthday today! Looking forward to making my copy very used.
Thanks for the reading list Joe and thanks Scott for getting Joe to do this. You are both legends in your own rights in my opinion
Many of those books are already on my bookshelf. I would also instinctively put Watson’s Cyclops first on my list, he has great style that is never self-indulgent. Now if there just more from Roy DeCarava in print…