The Best Thing I’ve Done for My Photography In The Past Year
So last week Joe McNally was down here at the Kelby Training Studios recording a new online class, and between tapings I asked Joe if he would mind sitting down with me for a few minutes to give me a portfolio review (gulp!).
This wasn’t my first portfolio review with Joe; he had given me one about two years ago, and it was a real turning point for me, and I wanted to have him take a look at some of my more recent work. I told Joe not to sugarcoat it or go easy on me because we’re friends, and he assured me he would give it to me straight.
He spent about 25 minutes with me, and I have to tell you; it was incredibly helpful, and I learned things I couldn’t have learned any other way. He absolutely gives you the straight scoop; the good and the bad, but that’s exactly what I needed, and I honestly believe what I learned in that 25 minutes will change how I approach my photography from now on. I was really frustrated with an area of my photography, and Joe helped me see things in a different way, and mentally break through that barrier.
Now, the reason I’m telling you this is this; you might be thinking to yourself, “Oh yeah, sure, it must be nice to be able to have someone like Joe McNally sit down and give you a one-on-one review,” and honestly it is. But the thing is; you can have Joe review your portfolio, too. Believe it or not, Joe does one-on-one portfolio reviews, for free, at Photoshop World. Every Photoshop World, including the one coming up at the end of March.
It’s not just Joe, it’s people like Moose Peterson (shown above during a portfolio review), and Jim DiVitale, along with some of the top photographers in their fields, and while they give you the straight scoop on your work; they’re not there to tear you down, or make your feel bad—they’re doing this to help you become a better photographer, and if you’ve never had a portfolio review by a pro; I promise you, it is an amazing experience that (if you follow their sage advice), will make you a better photographer.
When I’ve done week-long workshops, I always include a one-on-one portfolio review for my students, and when I read the final evaluations at the end of the workshop, invariably the students note that having their portfolio reviewed was one of the most valuable parts of the workshop.
Anyway, if you’re going to Photoshop World, I just can’t encourage you enough to take advantage of this, and have your portfolio reviewed by one of these experts. These are filled on a first-come, first-served basis, so make sure you sign up in advance for these free, yet absolutely invaluable insights into your work. If you’re not going to Photoshop World, it’s not too late (here’s the link).




















I had Rick Sammon do my portfolio review when I was at PSW last year and I learned a lot.
It’s really great to feedback (both good and bad) because I know that it’s one of the great ways for me to improve my craft.
Scott – you already have a lot of great photos, I’d be interested to find out what else you could improve on based on Joe’s comments…
Hello Scott,
I would love to get one on :
http://photoserge.com/portfolio/
But I leave in paris and going to Boston is a bit far, any chance you do a photoshop world in europe ? Or a service on line ?
Serge
so what are some of the things joe said about your portfolio, scott?
I have to totally agree Scott! Last year’s Photoshop World in Orlando Joe McNally reviewed my portfolio and I pretty much felt the same way after as you. He actually challenged me to try taking a new direction with my photography. Giving me a whole new perspective in photography to get me out of my comfortable zone as he put it. I would highly recommend going to the portfolio review!
great post! i learned a bit just with this shot of you in action…
maybe you could do a post about what makes up a good portfolio for a review… looks like you have what 11×14s with chunky white borders?
as a new photographer, i would be appreciative!
Wow Scott,
you are a brave soul…..
I don’t take rejection or criticism (though constructive) very well…
my pocketbook does not permit me to come to Photo world…but I was coming I would put on a disguise before letting someone critique my work
insecure in KY
Ken
I have taken some modeling photos of my daughter. She very interested in getting into modeling. Who do you suggest I get to make up a portfolio book. I have looked into Mpix but did not see any kind of portfolio books. I did see the hard backs will that work. Any help would be great.
O.K. let me get this straight. You, Scott Kelby, know about lighting techniques and exposure; you have some of the best equipment and you know how to use it; and you know Photoshop like the back of your hand. Why do I get the feeling that any conversation you would have with Joe McNally would be so far over my head that ……
Even so, I would have loved to hear it.
Gene
Scott maybe you can give us some insight of how to best present a portfolio for an editor to look at. What are the common methods and products editors would recommend.
When you see folks standing in line for the portfolio reviews at PSW, its always interesting to see how many different styles of portfolios there are. Some folks have their images on a slideshow on their computers, some have the large folio of mounted prints, sometimes it’s as simple as a photo album. I think the real key to a good portfolio isn’t necessarily the way you present your images but rather which images you present. It’s hard to summarize your complete body of work in about 12 to 15 images but that is the best way to do it. Force yourself to really find your best work and edit your shots down to as few as possible while still being able to represent your entire portfolio. Forcing yourself to go through that type of selection will probably be harder than any portfolio review you ever receive.
Wow, this is great advice…I would be interested in doing this myself. I’m sure I would have to get some thick skin in a hurry…but I also know it would help a ton too!
Thanks Scott!
I second the motion for you to do a blog about putting together a portfolio. 11X14? Borders? What kind of folder?
Thanks
Debbi
That’s awesome. I’m glad you guys are doing the design portfolios as well now too, or so I hear.
I was lucky enough to have Joe do a 15 min critique of my photos at Moose’s DLWS in Vermont last October. He’s a great guy, very easy to talk to..just down to earth. His comments really helped me.