What I Learned About Lightroom at Joe McNally’s Workshop
Do you have something that you really want to learn in Lightroom? Great. Hold that thought in your head right now (we’ll come back to it in just a moment).
While I was down in St. Lucia, teaching my Lightroom session at Joe’s workshop, I had to smile a number of times because I realized how much different teaching Lightroom is from teaching Photoshop. I think the reason is; Lightroom is just so much easier, that the questions I can answer in one quick sentence have a bigger impact for Lightroom users than they do when people ask their questions about Photoshop.
Here’s what I mean:
When I do a Photoshop seminar, people often come up to me before class and ask really broad questions like, “Are you going to teach us Curves today?” or “Are we going to discuss Color Management?” or “Are you going to go over Selective Color?” But in Lightroom, since it’s so much easier and intuitive, the questions are much more likely to be little things that people are stuck on, because the big things are pretty easy. Usually, they just want to know how to do one certain thing—-like does a particular shortcut exist for what they want to do, or is there a fast way to do a particular task, and once they learn it, it’s like it made their whole month. You can see it on their face (and then you can see it on mine).
I see it again and again. I saw it for four days at my Savannah Workshop last month, and I saw it a half dozen times in my class in St. Lucia, and when people got their answer, they were so genuinely happy—-because that was “that one little thing” that was driving them crazy.
I remember one question where the guy didn’t like using the Gradient Filter tool in Lightroom 2 because he couldn’t get it to draw in the straight line from top to bottom—it always rotated left or right on him as he dragged it, and was there any possible way to make it go straight? There is. I told him to hold the Shift key before he dragged. He tried it right there on the spot, and he just got the biggest grin on his face. So did I. Now, he’ll actually start using that feature, and I think that’s really cool.
Things like this happened again and again in the past few months, and I love being able to help out with stuff like that. I don’t always have the answer, or sometimes the answer is “Sorry, there’s no way to do that,” but more often than not; it can be done, it’s just not real obvious (like flipping the crop ratio from horizontal to vertical—-you guys who follow me on Twitter know what I’m talkin’ about).
Now, back to that thought you’re holding
If your “thing” is something like that, today I invite you to post your question as a comment here on my blog, and if I know the answer, I’ll post a reply with it. Someone else might beat me to it (it’s a work-day for me, so I’ll be pretty busy), but I’ll be checking in quite a bit during the day, and if I can help open a new door, or a new feature, or just make something easier for you today, I’ll do my best (by the way; this offer’s only good today; Tuesday, July 14th).
Don’t forget; don’t ask big broad questions, like “What’s your workflow for portraiture?” or any question that starts with “Is there a way to write a script that….” But if you’ve got something like, “Is there a way to keep the White Balance tool from snapping back to it’s holder each time I use it? (another question from the past few workshops), then I’ll try and tackle those (by the way—there is; just click on the White Balance tool, then in the Toolbar below the main Preview area in the center of the screen, turn off the checkbox for “Auto Dismiss” as seen below).




















I have a Windows XP system on which I relocated the “My Documents” folder and all its contents to an external drive. Lightroom 2 keeps recreating the My Documents and My Pictures folders on Drive C. I think this happens when I Export images, but not sure. Any idea how I can fix this?
I would think it was Windows that is recreating those folders not Lightroom.
It only happens when I use LR, no other program that touches photos.
Hate when stuff like that happens! I would think it’ll be Windows too. Those folders are default location for so many programs, so it wouldn’t surprise me if windows insisted they were there! I ran into something similar when moving my music, itunes kept remaking the iTunes Music folder on C. (until i did “consolidate library”) If its remade (but empty), just try to forget about it;)
If you have physically relocated My Documents (i.e by cut and paste to the external drive) you need to undo that. After undoing it symply change the target of My Documents to a folder located to your external drive. It will solve your problem.
I have been wanting to understand (ever since LR came out) how to use the web module with my mobile me account. Currently I just load things using iweb but I would love, love, LOVE to be able to use the web settings within LR and not be “stuck” with iweb. I have looked at other apple blogs to figure out how to do it but I need a step by step how to. My operating system is os x.5.7.
Give this a try:
http://blogs.adobe.com/lightroomjournal/2007/03/how_do_you_upload_to_mac_dot_m_1.html
I have another question concerning sharpening. I think I saw somewhere on NAPP that there are two levels of sharpening. I sharpen within the develop module but then get confused about printer sharpening in the print module. Am I suppose to do both? Or will I be oversharpening if I do it in both modules?
Hi Kathleen:
If you shoot in Raw, Lightroom will automatically apply a small amount of sharpening (call Capture Sharpening) to your images by default (if you shoot in JPEG or TIFF, this is turned off). So, here’s how I handle sharpening in Lightroom; if I’m not going to Photoshop at all (which is my goal), then I’ll do all my sharpening in Lightroom (1) First I’ll increase the Sharpening amount in the Detail panel, then (2) When I export the Raw file as a JPEG, or if I print it, I then add the Output Sharpening, since I won’t be adding any sharpening in Photoshop (since my entire workflow will be in Lightroom from start to finish).
However, if at some point I think I’m going over to Photoshop, then I usually do my Output sharpening there (though I still do the Capture sharpening in Lightroom), mostly because it’s easier to see the effects of Sharpening on screen in Photoshop than it is in Lightroom (even at a 1:1 view).
Anyway, that’s how I decide what to do when.
Hope that helps.
-Scott
Hi,
My work flow starts in RAW and ends in JPG… that is, after I’m done processing all my RAW files in LR, then I export to JPG and discard the RAW files (yes, I live on the edge!).
I didn’t used to do any output sharpening when I exported to JPG – which I will do now based on reading this… but which setting is best to use if I don’t know how the pictures will be printed in the future? the current settings let you choose between screen, matte and glossy paper.
What is your recommendation?
Thanks!
If I’m reading this right, and pls correct me if I’m not, then Scott is in fact double sharpening, and that could get nasty!
I remembered this video on the topic: http://www.thedigitalphotographyconnection.com/LFDP_player.php?ID=82
It concludes, stick to one of the sharpenings.
Ali M: Discarding the RAW files sound a bit odd. Why save the JPG all the time? Once printed, why do you need it anymore? Sharpening for print and sharpening for screen/monitors might require different levels of sharpening,(even different gloss of paper and probably different types of monitors even if your “hard core” enough;) This is when the RAW file is very good to have, as it enables you to start from “scratch” again. This is a key element to the RAW and Lightroom philosophy the way I see it!?
Hi,
regarding to Bryan. the is a nice tutorial from Matt on the Lightroom Killer Tipps web site about the video from “the digitalphotograpyconnection.com” website. In general it says that you have of course different states of sharpening and yes of course you have to verify what you are doing. If you do to much capture sharpening or detail sharpening then it may end in a oversharped Picture after output sharpening. Have a look I think it really gives the right answer and advise.
Kai
Is there any way to post a LR slideshow onto Blogger?
I understand how to create a slideshow with LR, but have no idea how to post it on my blog. There is a reason I use a pre-fab blog page……… I don’t really understand much code. That’s what it’s called, right? Code?
Hi Johnny:
Unfortunately, the only way to post it to a Web site (at this point in Lightroom’s evolution), is to save it as a PDF, and then post it for download (but sadly it won’t have music, which is an entirely different topic that drives me crazy. Don’t get me started).
If you want people to see a slideshow, your best bet may be to create a Flash-based Web gallery (using Lightroom’s Web module) and they come with a built-in slideshow feature (try the one called Airtight Auto Viewer, up in the Engine panel at the top of the Right Side panels).
Hope that helps.
-Scott
Maybe the Slideshow Pro-plugin is the solution here? Look here http://slideshowpro.net/products/slideshowpro/slideshowpro_for_lightroom
Kind regards
John
Scott,
Can’t you embed a song or multiple songs into PDFs using Acrobat?
Metadata fields like Location and Category don’t seem to remember more than a few recent items while keywords remembers them all. Is there a way to get Location, City, State, Category and others to remember everything like Keywords does?
I’ve never understood why Location and Category (and City, State, etc) do not give you access to every item you’ve entered when you type into those fields (like keywords does).
I have to keep another app open (DevonTHINK) where I keep the full list – and then I have to copy/paste between there and LR when I do metadata work. This just seems plain wrong.
Also, why can’t I search on Category specifically and why did they remove time from the date/time filters we had in early LR previews?? Those are other things I’ve not been able to understand.
If you have an answer for any of these, I’ll have the biggest damn smile you ever saw!
-mike (mbryan2 gmail com)
I think all in all what I’ve loved about today? The fact that it wasn’t just Scott replying. EVERYONE took part. A community of like minded people have come together for the benefit of each other.
Fantastic.
Thanks everybody.
Cheers,
Kris
Hi Kris:
I feel exactly the same way.
-Scott
Scott / Matt / Anyone
I have a number of keyword sets set up, but there are about 5 or so “regular” keywords that I always come back to (names of the members of my family). Is there a way to create a keyboard shortcut for these common keywords?
Cheers!
Hi Rope:
There isn’t a keyboard shortcut per se, but you could create a “Keyword Set” so at least those keywords would be just one click away (one click maybe quicker than a two-handed keyboard shortcut). You create these sets in the Keywording panel.
Hope that helps.
-Scott
P.S. I love the idea of having a set of keywords assigned to a keyboard shortcut though.
Once you have the keyword set defined & loaded, doesn’t ALT-1, ALT-2 etc give you the shortcuts for the first nine keywords? Arranged in the form of the Numpad, too
Thanks Dorfl (and Scott of course) – you’ve made me a very happy man!
Cheers
Rope
Can LR move photos from one catalog to another and also from one folder to another on the hard drive?
Hi Matt:
You can drag images from one Folder to another folder. Just click on the photo you want to move in the Library Grid, then drag and drop it onto the folder where you want it.
As for Catalogs; you can Export a collection as a Catalog using Export as Catalog, then open the other catalog where you want it to live, then choose Import from Catalog.
Hope that helps.
-Scott
Can I copy 4 layers I created, from one Photo Shop file to another? (PhotoShop CS4)
Bob, try right clicking on the layer, select duplicate layer; then choose the other file in the drop down box. You must have both files open in Photoshop to do this.
If you choose Duplicate it’s just going to create another layer in that file. You choose to copy it and add it in the other photo or, if you have them side-by-side or where you can see both, then highlight the layer (or layers, Ctrl/Cmnd + click multiple layers) and then drag the highlighted layer(s) from your source image and drop it onto the other image or its’ Layer dialog box.
Slideshow module > Titles > check Ending Screen (or Intro Screen) > check Add ID Plate. Click on the default ID Plate shown in the box, select edit and create and save a new ID Plate such as “The End”. If I change my mind, how do I delete this new ID Plate? If I want to edit this ID Plate, I can save with a new name but how do I delete the original ID Plate I created?
Hi Dan:
Here’s what you do:
Step One: Go to the Identity Plate Editor, and from the Custom pop-up menu choose the Identity Plate you want to delete.
Step Two: Choose Remove from that same pop-up menu, and it removes the saved Identity Plate you just selected.
Hope that helps.
-Scott
If you open the ID Plate editor from Edit > ID Plate Setup, and follow your directions, no problem deleting just as you said – thank you very much. But if you open the ID Plate editor from the slide show module as I described, the Delete function is grayed and thus not available. Interesting!!
Does LightRoom use any up-rezing algorythms to enlarge image files when they are printed directly out of LR?
Yes, it uses an adaptive bicubic algorithm, a more sophisticated approach to that found in Photoshop (kind of a steeples up or down resampling).
How can I paint an area a specific color using the adjustment brush tool and the color picker? This has not worked well for me at all….
I think this video might help, not sure
http://www.lightroomkillertips.com/2008/video-the-adjustment-brush-color-swatch/?cp=1
How about getting to the top of the right hand pannel in Develop Module quickly without scrolling? That is, if I edit a photo using the tools in the order they’re displayed then hit the right arrow to go to the next photo I always have to scroll back up to the top of the tools in the pannel
Hi Pete:
There’s not a shortcut per se, but what you can try is using Solo Mode, where only the panel you’re currently working on is displayed in the Develop module’s Right side panels. This makes your panel list much, much shorter, and helps to keep you from scrolling too much. You turn this on by Ctrl-clicking (PC: Right-clicking) to the left of any panel’s name, and then choose Solo Mode from the pop-up menu that appears.
Hope that helps.
-Scott
Thanks, again something I didn’t know about, I’ll give it a go.
Do you mean changing the tool panel? Because Ctrl+1 ?PC) will open the basic panel. Also Ctrl+7 is for Camera Calibration, and all the other panels are in between.
Solo mode is brilliant! I didn’t know it was there. Thanks for the great tip.
My adjustment brush disappears when I try to resize it smaller, the finally reappears when it is verrrry small. But many middle sizes just don’t show up at all–only very large or very small. any ideas why?
Thanks
Chris
Hi, I had a similar problems on PC for months, then one day someone suggested removing the microsoft inteli mouse drivers, this fixed it instantly. Try it, it only takes a moment, good luck.
Scott -
Since folks seem to be putting these in as fast as you answer them, if you’ve already answered this, say answered and I’ll go searching.
Is there a quick way to add several keywords under another without having to add one, right-click on the parent keyword, select add under parent keyword, etc.?
Rick
Oooohh!! Oooohh! I got this one!! (and I’m NEW at this!).
In windows, right click on the keyword you want to use as the “parent” keyword. Click on “Put new keywords inside this keyword”, and then from that point on, any new keywords you create will automatically get placed under the parent. When you’re done, right click the parent keyword again, and uncheck that mode.
How’d I do Scott?? I totally see how answering Lightroom questions gives the answerer as much instant gratification as the questioner!
To add a keyword under a parent keyword directly in the keyword entering panel, type in the new keyword, and let it follow by a “>” and the name of the parent keyword. e.g., “ape > animal”. I use that a lot…
Thanks Dawn and Adriano – I’ll give both a try!
Rick
This has been a great resource of information all day long. Thanks to all (esp. Scott) for all the time and information. I have one more question to pose if anyone else is still “tuned in”. When in the develop mode, I love to change the ratio to different sizes to see what kind of different crops I could achieve. For example, if I change to 1:2 in the navigator and then more the box around and I like that look, is there anyway to just crop it like that without having to enter command R and then crop it manually. I would love a shortcut that crops it as I see it when zoomed in to that ratio.
(Sorry if I used the wrong terms to describe my question.)
p.s Can’t wait for the photowalk. I am driving from St. Augustine to Tampa to join in with your group Scott. See ya there!
Hi Kathleen:
I don’t know of a way to do that, but I have to say; that would make a great feature!
See you Saturday! (and drive carefully).
-Scott
Couldn’t you just have a different set of develop presets which are just for applying different crop ratios?
Where can I find the EXIF data for an individual image in LR? I can filter my library based in EXIF Data (in the metadata section of library), but can’t find the details for just one image.
Tks…
Hi Shelley:
In the Library Module, click on the photo you want to see the EXIF data for, then scroll down to the Metadata panel. In the Metadata Panel, choose EXIF from the pop-up menu to the left of the title “Metadata.” That will show the EXIF data for just the selected photo.
Hope that helps.
-Scott
When creating an identity plate in photoshop what size and res should I make the file.
I’m trying to add my signture with my new wacom 4 tablet, thanks for everything
Doug
I make mine 240 ppi.
Make it larger than you’ll think you’ll need; there’s a Scale slider that lets you shrink the size once you’ve applied the signature as an Identity plate.
Hope that helps.
-Scott
I would like to export a gallery to put on a dvd, can I do this straight out of LR2?
Im on PC
Fred
Hi Scott
Is there a way to get Lightroom to show the number of photos using a particular key word in a collection or even in a selection (like Bridge — if I select 20 photos, Bridge will tell me keyword I appears 6 times, II appears 4 times etc). Thanks!
Hi LS3:
Look in the Library Module’s Keywording Panel, and you’ll see a list of all the keywords applied, then how many photos have that keyword. If you click on the keyword, it will display just those photos that have that keyword.
Hope that helps.
-Scott
Scott, this is an incredibly cool and generous thing you’ve done today. It’s going to take some time to go through all of these questions and answers!
My biggest Lightroom problem (and obviously this isn’t a question to answer) is that sometimes I import tons of photos within a short amount of time and don’t get them keyworded properly (like now). If that doesn’t get done, it’s almost like they don’t exist because I don’t find them in my searches.
When I hit that wall I’ll put something quick (and unique) like the name of a shoot, date/time, or day of the year in the keyword box in the Import dialog panel. That way I can come back later and sort just those photos and then spend some quality time labeling them. Best of all, it only takes 1-2 seconds but it saves tons later.
Hey Dawn,
I kinda do what Lee does. I name my folders something descriptive to the shoot. I’ve pretty much given up on keywording for my purposes. It took longer for me to find them by keywords, then it did for me to just click on the folder or collection I’d created that had a descriptive name.
Hope you’re doing well!
- Matt K
Yeah, I give them a big, generic keyword, but I like to have individual people keyworded, too. For instance, I recently took 250 pictures at the GA Aquarium. They’re all keyworded with “aquarium,” but none of the shots with family members are keyworded, yet.
A couple of months ago I found a huge folder of pictures from our vacation last year where I hadn’t keyworded the people. It was like discovering buried treasure: those pictures hadn’t been showing up in my keyword searches by person.
Lee, I need to take some of that “quality labeling time” you were talking about. Matt, I do give the folders descriptive labels, but I tend to search more by keyword than folder. Maybe that’s part of my problem.
Blessings,
Dawn
keywording 250 slides for 5 family members, activities (like “sleeping”, “running”) and items (like “boat”, “water”) and animals takes me about 2-3 hours.
my workflow for that
(1) grid mode
(2) painter tool
(3) hide left an right panel
(4) thumbnail such that I can recognize the people. This is actually fairly easy as you often remember who was on
(5) for n = 1 to all family members, locations, animals
(6) set painter to keyword for family member n (e.g., “Mike”)
(7) Paint all pictures. Yes, this will require some scrolling but you get a lot of pictures on one screen
(8) next (n)
(9) do the odds an ends
When I don’t have time to keyword an import I just set all the images in the import to have a yellow color label. Then when I have time to catch up I just kick in a filter to display all the yellow labeled pictures and keyword away, removing the yellow label when I’m finished with a number of files.
I find this works better than filtering for pictures that have no keywords because as soon as you add one keyword the picture disappears from the list.
Actually, now that I think about, more like 1-2 hours. The 2-3 last time included selecting the pictures and some minor adjustments
I use a tag like %filter, %tag or %workset to import my images. The % will always apear on the top of the keyword list. May help
Not big on key-wording myself, but I know a friend of mine used to have a collection that was named “Unsorted” or “unedited” or something like that. He had lot in there!
Or you could add keyword like “in process” “almost done” more kw pls”? (…and of course remove the keyword when done;)
For my purposes I have a few basic keywords that are crucial, and are the base of any keyword search. To allow myself to be lazy, but not forget unprocessed pics.. I always apply a few tags to newly imported sets:
missing_venue
missing_band
etc..
You could use %venue, etc.. it just depends on how you want to do it.
The point is, when you apply the venue, you remove the missing_venue.
I think this addresses what you’re getting at, if not perfectly.
(This was not an original idea, I read it somewhere)
Hi everybody…
I’m new here but an old user of LR from beta4, so I have several hundred thousands pictures in my lightroom. So keywording is very important to me, but also the exact location where the picture was taken. I tried many ways to make sure I dont forget to tag each photo with keywords and proper location, and the best way I found was as this :
I import photos from folders on my hard disk, and most of the times the pictures inside the same folder were shot at the same place, on on the same trip.
I select all pictures imported then input scene, location, city, country country ISO code, and I leave ‘region’ blank (I use lightroom in French version so I’m not sure these labels are exactly like this in english, but you’ll guess).
Then I put the metadata filter ON in the library, and filter photos on regions, so only the ‘region unknown’ photos are on the screen. And when I have keyworded properly a photo, or a group of photos, then I select this group, and input the region info. This puts these properly tagged pictures away from the screen…
Hi Scott, i have photos over multiple drives. I created a “Collection” for posting a portfolio online. There was no physical way of having ALL the drives connected to the computer at once to do the export in the Web module.
1. Do you have to export all the photos to a separate folder (a bit at a time across all the drives) then re-import to LR from one drive to do the Web export? Is that clear?
2. As a fellow musician who has been shooting professionally for 15 years, what’s the deal with all these music types doing photography?
thanks for the help.
rob
When I first open CS4 (before I open an image) the window opens up below the bottom of my screen and I cannot grab the corner to resize it to fit. I am on Mac OS 10.5.7.
Thank you.
Amelia
Go into the Monitor Control Panel, alter the display resolution such that you can now grab the window to reposition, then reset the display resolution back.
I changed the resolution to each possible setting and could not get it to the point where I could reach the bottom right corner. I even tried altering settings on my NEC multisync 2690 monitor. This only happens in CS4 not lightroom.
Any other possible answers.
Thanks again,
Amelia
IF its only Photoshop, try deleting your preferences. Press Option+Command+Shift (Mac OS) immediately after launching Photoshop. Might fix it.
Thank you. Deleting the preferences fixed the problem.
Thank you again
Amelia
I see this sometimes when I open programs using my MacBook’s laptop screen after having run them on a larger screen (in clamshell mode)…
The non-Ps specific solution is to Option-click the zoom button (the green circle in the top left-hand corner of the application’s window). That will resize the window of the application to take the maximum screen real estate possible outside of the menu bar and the dock. This works for lots of programs including Word 2008, Logic, even iTunes.
Hi Scott,
I have had all my photos stored on an external and my .lrcat on my macbook.
For some reason I get ???’s on some of my photos, even though they are still in the same spot as always. It’s really strange, and I end up having to reimport them back in.
Driving me crazy for sure. Ever seen this?
Thanks for being awesome!
Chris,
That has happened to me too a few times. One thing you might try is while in the Library Module right-click/ctrl-click(Mac) on the folder name and click “Locate Missing Folder” and see how that works. I think sometimes when storing images on externals the connection gets severed when the drive is diconnected or powered off. Hope this will help you out…
Thank’s Jason!
I’ll give that a shot.
Appreciate it.
Scott – I would like to divide a long photo into 3 equal parts (to be printed/mounted separately). Is there a way to do that in LR? Thanks!
Maybe create 3 virtual copies and crop each photo to the specific area of the whole photo you would like to crop??? Just guessing but I think that would be an easy fix…now you’ve got me brainstorming…lol
Hey guys,
I have a question based on something I saw Matt do in a before and after video on Lightroom Killer Tips… When Matt bounces into Photoshop from Lightroom to edit, he’s able to go to file>save and it bounces back to lightroom automatically. When I do it, it just gives me the save file box, so I save the psd file and then have to reimport it into LR. I follow his steps to the letter, except that I have to rasterize the second smart object I create (via copy, in the layers menu) in order to perform my cloning.
Could this be a version issue? I”m using LR 2.4 and CS3.
Thanks!
Hi Justin
I’m not sure but I think this will only work in CS4. I had the same issue until I upgraded to CS4 and then I coudl open as a smart object on photoshop.
Just wonder if the camera profiles included in version 2.4 are the latest
Yes, the Adobe Standard profiles in Lightroom 2.4 are the latest camera profiles. (If you don’t see a version number next to it then the profile hasn’t changed since it was originally created)
Regards,
Tom
Hi Scott,
My camera is set to capture .nef and .jpg at the same time. For ease of speed and quick rendering while I edit my weddings in LR…I’m only tagging my selection (keepers) .jpgs with the green label. However, I then want to do my color and density corrections on the raw files.
My question is…
Can you generate and export side car .xmp files (which carry the green label for my select) from the .jpg folder and then move/copy them to the Raw folder which has all my .nef’s? In other words (if I’m not being clear), I want to tag my favorite .jpgs shots…and then apply those tags to the raw folder so that LR can quickly sort my .nef by the green tags.
In theory, because the file names are the same (except for the extension), a side car .xmp file should do the trick, right?
Problem is, I can’t seem to generate a side car file from my .jpgs. Is this at all possible with Lightroom v2 or is it all wishful thinking?
Thanks so much for any insight into this?
JPG and DNG don’t have sidecars, the metadata is written inside the JPG or DNG file.
RAW are propietary files, so nobody writes nothing on them, thus generating the sidecars.
Not easy what you ask, order by filename and as the names are the same just add green label quickly in grid view to those next to a green JPG?
Hi Trevor,
there is a switch in the Preference Dialog on the Import Tab. It should be called keep jpg next to raw as seperate files (I don’t know the english text as ‘m on a german Lightroom.) If you deselect this Lightroom will share one xmp file for both files therefore if you change some tag on the jpg it will show up for the raw as well. theonly drawback is that this works only for new imports not the existing ones as far as I know.
Hope that helps
Kai
Kai
>Problem is, I can’t seem to generate a side car file from my .jpgs.
Sidecar’s are only used with Raws (because Raw’s are basically read only). The same metadata data is embedded into the JPEG so no, this isn’t going to fly.
Thanks Andrew. That’s what I feared.
Scott,
When I right click a photo to take it to Photo Shop the option window dose not appear
(the one that lets you change to ProPhoto or Tiff and change the bit depth) Is there something in there a way to turn that on and off. Thanks in advance.
Have updated my ordinary Lightroom 2.4 with Adobe Photoshop Lightroom 2.4 – multiple languages Still I have only the standard three languages. Tried twice
Uninstalled Lightroom 4 and reinstalled Adobe Photoshop Lightroom 2.4 – multiple languages. Now I found the Swedish language in the Preferences
–> General
I’m currently using Lightroom 2.1. Once the raw files have been imported, I click on an image and LM auto adjust the tone on the photos. This is really annoying and I haven’t been able to find a way to disable it. Any ideas?
Its replacing the low rez JPEG preview generated by the camera to the high quality previews based on the current default rendering. No, you can’t change this behavior but you could attempt to build a default preset or play with other DNG profiles to produce a closer match to the initial JPEG previews from the camera.
When I am going through the photos I just took in Library mode, I like to quickly adjust the WB so I can get an idea of what they actually look like with proper coloring. I generally use the dropper. Is there some way for me to call in the dropper without having to constantly switch to Develop and then back after the fix?
No, dropper always works in Develop. But you can do this once and of course, copy and paste those settings into other images within Grid in Library.
Scott, I use the histogram in LR by click and drag. I noticed that the tones in the image change according to where I click. I understand this but please explain the proper or preferred way to use this method
Hi Scott,
I really enjoy your dtowntv shows. Great stuff. Just need to know 1 thing in lightroom. Actually I’m not too much into editing the pictures in Lightroom & Photoshop and in fact am pretty much new to it. I checked your Tuscany pictures and was amazed by the effect where the corners were darkened and a circle in the middle was in bright focus. Could I please know how to get that effect?
Thanks,
Mrudwang.
That effect is known as vignetting. An easy way to do it in Lightroom is to go to the Develop module and scroll down the right hand side until you see the Vignette options. Play around with these settings until you like the result. You should use the “post crop vignette” if you have cropped the original photo. Have fun!
I edit on three macs and would love to easily keep them all up to date…i understand export as catalogue but has anybody figured out the best way…like is exporting the top level folder (say ‘09) as a catatalogue and importing to same folder on another machine gonna get it…not take forever?
Thanks!
I clone the entire drive using a 3rd party utility (on Mac, SuperDuper). It only clones changes made to that drive. My drives are all fully dedicated ONLY to LR (so all photos, presets, library etc). If on drive A, I’ve updated 5 images, when I clone to drive B, only that gets updated, keeping everything in sync and quickly. The key is keeping the drives dedicated to only LR and using some software product that clones by only altering updated data.
If you’re a somewhat advanced ‘puter user, there are solutions outside of Lightroom that focus on synchronizing the files themselves. Rsync, Unison, etc.. (google to find info). Be careful, syncing is tricky stuff, with the potential to corrupt and erase large amounts of data automatically. If unsure, please stick with copying data.
Hi Scott/everyone,
I was wondering if you could help out a little thing that bugs me when I use the print module. Let’s say I crop my photos at exactly 5×7″ and I want to output them into 5×7″ files for printing in the Print Module. My paper size is exactly 5×7″ but it doesn’t seem to fill out the “paper” on screen. I have to click on the “zoom to fill” option which fixes things but sometimes I do critical cropping where a slightest change sort of ruins it for me.
Any help?
If it’s not too late; I have a question about printing. If I get something the way I want to print it in the print module; but I want to send it to someone else online to print it; how can I save it as a jpg to be able to send it to an online printer?
There’s a save for JPEG in the Print Module (Print Job area)
386 posts so far in this thread and not one single word about THE Number one “biggie” on Kelby’s list of MUST-Have’s in Lightroom 2.x – (he was writing about 2.0 at the time and we’re now up to 2.4) – and *still* NO CENTRAL NETWORKING capability in Lightroom! How can this be? Is anyone at Adobe listening to their user base? Who exactly are they targeting with this product, other than “Professional Photographers”, enthusiasts, and photogs like me who aspire to greatness someday? And yet we *STILL* have NO CENTRAL NETWORK ACCESS TO OUR DATA USING LIGHTROOM 2.4. I find this unbelievable in 2009 for a “Professional-grade”, $300 product like this!
Barring this single major omission, Lightroom is a GREAT program — and yet, virtually unusable to me (and I’m sure countless others) who have no alternative, as 100% of our data is residing on centrally managed file servers where all of our precious data is backed-up, managed, cared-for and loved (as it should be) in a Central File Server environment; which in my particular case is presently sitting at 12TB and growing by ~ 2gb day. And yet, Adobe continues to refuse to address this most core-issue that is lacking in this “Professional-Grade” product. Scott (and Joe) – to me this is unfathomable at this version of the product cycle. You were squawking about this loud-and-clear at ver 2.0 many months ago and now here we are today 4 iterations later, and *still* no networking!
I have been forced to use 3rd-party “work-arounds” like Microsoft’s SyncToy 2.0 which is really quite nice — and yet — limited in that I can only “sync” a limited amount of stuff due to my local hard-drive limitations; I mean, is Adobe expecting me to “sync” 12TB of photos locally! What, are they nuts? Using SyncToy, at least I go in over the network and drill-down to selected folders of more current work and then “sync” that locally to my machine to that Lightroom can work with it. What kind of mickey-mouse work-flow is this? But, I do what I have to do for now. I am forced to have to use a 3rd-party tool like this, when Adobe should have addressed this major shortcoming a LONG TIME AGO? Hello? Adobe? Is anyone listening over there? I’m not being facetious here – as far as I can tell, this issue has been beaten over their heads for years — and its been continually ignored?
Adobe — ditch the SQLite — develop Lightroom 2.5 with any decent rdbms – MySQL, MS-SQL, heck just use JET if you have too! But do something! Please. We ***NEED*** central-network access to our catalogs / library’s. Soon.
I’ll step down from my soap box now, as I realize that this is completely off-topic here. It’s just that I need to find every avenue and opportunity I can to help “grind some gears” and hopefully gain someones attention over at Adobe. — thank you –
Question: Is there any way I can soft-proof in Lightroom.
Answer: Uhh, no.
C’mon Adobe!
I just posted a note before I read yours. I am trying to do a similar thing with my little network between my laptop and my computer — both macs, as I edit lightroom files on both my laptop and desktop. I think I might have to buy a 3rd party program — Remote Desktop, but it’s very expensive and I don’t know if it will work. I don’t mind workarounds, but I don’t want to have to remember to email myself the latest catalog each time I make a change. It’s driving me nuts. Thanks to anyone who can provide assistance. Freddi
Scott,
My wife loves jpgs for their ease of use, but I shoot in RAW (cause I’m awesome like that, and love to edit stuff in lightroom). I’m rockin’ and old-school Maxxum 7D and realized I could shoot in RAW+JPG. When I import photos on my computer, is there a way I can separate the RAW from the JPG into two discrete folders on import? It would make managing pictures of the kids much easier.
Thanks.
And I have a similar question. Normally I just import the RAW-files but every now and then i forget to remove the jpgs before importing and end up with raw+jpg everywhere… To me this is just useless (cause really, whats that jpg for anyway?). Is there any way of deleting just the jpgs but keep the raws?
Thanks.
How can I fix a flare in an image using Lightroom or LR2? I have never seen this problem addressed in any forum or book.
Thanks…Mark
I don’t know if this is too broad or not, but I am having some issues undertanding catalogs. For instance, I have folders for every year and month (ie, June09) on my external hard drive and C drive. I would like to keep this same organization with my LR 2 library. Would I just create a new catalog for every year and month? Sorry for the remedial question, but I can’t grasp this concept!
Of course you can. Catalog is afile Lightroom 2.lrcat that keeps track of your photos. It’s a single file, but the photos can be (and usually are) on multiple folders.
In iTunes you have the iTunes library who knows in what folder songs are, what rating they have etc, in LR is the same, create a catalog, import as many photos as you want to it from whatever folder (Choose the option “add to catalog without moving” and LR will respect the original locations of the images, maybe you’re getting “Move to one folder” or the like) and then keep track of the keywording, rating, develop actions of each photo in just that file that grows up constantly in size, obviously.
I use Lightroom interchangeably on my Mac Pro and my MacBook Air, the two are connected through the public drive on each via a network. I want to figure out how to connect the 2 lightroom folders. I know how to export, but I make a small changes on both computers each day for a couple of weeks until I finalize and publish the results. How can I do this, do I need to buy Apple Remote Desktop 3? Would this work? Any helpful hints or work arounds would be appreciated. Freddi
Scot, Matt, anyone,
I’ve been watching/learning from Matt on Kelby Training about LR 2.4 and softening skin using the adjustment brush. I am finding that since making some multiple adjustments using the brush, on a test photo, that photo now takes forever to preview, and when making adjustments I get the spinning ball constantly. Any ideas on why this is happening? My system includes: Mac Pro 2.66 8Gig of RAM over 360Gig of free space on my HDD..
I attended the lightroom seminar at Javits in NYC today. It was GREAT!
Can you apply a CROP preset upon import?
I wanted to create a preset 4×6 (to be applied upon import to all pixs from the nikon POS) when my daughter uses her NIKON POS, because it has the annoying 4 x 5.3 ratio, requiring cropping of ALL pics.
HOWEVER, I do not see this as an option in the dialogue box for presets. Is this possible? (I AM ABLE TO COPY THE CROP SETTING AND APPLY IT TO SUBSEQUENT PHOTOS WITH AN INDIVIDUAL PASTE, BUT THIS IS MONOTOUS AND TIME CONSUMING), I SEE YOU CAN DO IT WITH SYNCH, BUT IT WOULD BE NICE TO DO UPON IMPORT, no?)
THANKS
GAIL STARR
Using the crop tool I have great difficulty in switching orientations. Do you have any suggestions?
Also, in the crop tool, if I press the letter O, different grids show up, the default being lines at third points. What are the others used for.
Just keep rotating that pup, eventually it will snap to the newer orientation.
Scott— Please help–I think I am doing something stupid and obvious but I cant find it. I shoot in RAW with a Nikon D90, so pics are in the .NEF format. I try to import them into Lightroom via a card reader, and I am getting the message *No files to import*. Lightroom is not seeing the RAW files on my card. When I shoot in JPEG i have no problem and they load into Lightroom beautifully. The same RAW files are seen by Picassa and by NX2. Please—what am I doing wrong. As an aside, I loved your seminar on Lightroom in Denver this Spring, and I am an avid Kelby Online Student. Those courses are the best on the Web. Keep up the good work. See ya in Vegas.
Do you have latest LR update? D90 entered in the 2.1 version I think.
I am cruising the web trying to find out about running lightroom…..
I just moved my main LR database and actual files/images to a RAID server box, esata, while the lightroom application is of course on my main-internal mac drive.
When I open LR now, its pulling from this lrcat file that is on the RAID drive along with photos on the RAID drive.
I am wondering if I move the lrcat file to the internal and run it from the internal main hard drive (leaving images/files on the RAID drive) will I notice a performance increase? or will it stay the same-or worse?
thanks in advance!
Craig
I’m hoping anyone can answer this question-
When I’m about to export a photo from LR, and want to add a copyright watermark, is there any way to make it bigger than an inscrutable white thing on the bottom left hand corner?
Thanks a lot
I can’t seem to find Black and White colors in the color picker. Or am I missing something? Thanks!